BURT v. New York, #2000-015-001, Claim No. 099719, Motion No. M-60957
A discovery and inspection notice will be enforced if it is sufficiently
specific so as to enable the responding party to identify the information sought
and conduct a search therefrom.
Case Information
UID:
|
2000-015-001
|
Claimant(s):
|
ROBERT L. BURT
|
Claimant short
name:
|
BURT
|
Footnote (claimant name)
:
|
|
Defendant(s):
|
THE STATE OF NEW YORK
|
Footnote (defendant name)
:
|
|
Third-party
claimant(s):
|
|
Third-party
defendant(s):
|
|
Claim number(s):
|
099719
|
Motion number(s):
|
M-60957
|
Cross-motion
number(s):
|
|
Judge:
|
Francis T. Collins
|
Claimant's
attorney:
|
Robert L. Burt, Pro Se
|
Defendant's
attorney:
|
Honorable Eliot Spitzer, Attorney GeneralBy: Glenn C. King, Esquire, Staff Attorney
|
Third-party defendant's
attorney:
|
|
Signature date:
|
March 2, 2000
|
City:
|
Saratoga Springs
|
Comments:
|
|
Official citation:
|
|
Appellate results:
|
|
See also (multicaptioned
case)
|
|
The motion of claimant for an order pursuant to CPLR 3124 directing the
defendant to comply with his notice for discovery and inspection annexed as
Exhibit A to the affidavit submitted in support of the motion within thirty days
of the date of this decision and order by either serving copies of said
documents upon claimant or a sworn statement that after a diligent search such
documents could not be located is granted. This is a claim by an inmate
appearing pro se to recover for personal injuries allegedly caused by the
negligence and medical malpractice of employees of the Department of
Correctional Services. The first cause of action in the amended claim asserts
that claimant was transported on September 15, 1997 from Riverview Correctional
Facility to Coxsackie Correctional Facility in order to attend a court ordered
appearance in Albany County Court. It is alleged that claimant was then taken
by correction officers to the Albany County Correctional Facility and, on
September 16, 1997, was transported to the Albany County Courthouse where he was
given an adjourned date to appear in the Albany County Court. Claimant asserts
that instead of then returning claimant to Coxsackie Correctional Facility, DOCS
employees permitted him to be housed at the Albany County Correctional Facility
in disregard of orders to the contrary. The second cause of action asserts that
on October 4, 1997, at approximately 11:30 a.m., claimant slipped and fell upon
stairs located in the Albany County Correctional Facility. The third cause of
action alleges that on August 17, 1998 claimant was negligently prescribed
medication at Riverview Correctional Facility. Claimant served a discovery and
inspection notice upon the defendant containing the following requests:
TRANSPORTATION ORDER FOR CLAIMANT ROBERT BURT'S COURT APPEARANCE ON/OR ABOUT
SEPTEMBER 14TH 1997
NAMES OF TRANSPORTATION OFFICERS THAT TRANSPORTED CLAIMANT TO COXSACKIE
CORRECTIONAL FACILITY ON OR ABOUT SEPTEMBER 14TH 1997
HOUSING ORDERS FROM DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS FOR CLAIMANT ON OR ABOUT SEPTEMBER
14TH AND 15TH OF 1997
INTAKE, HOUSING AND RECEIVING DOCUMENTATION FROM COXSACKIE CORRECTIONAL FACILITY
ON ROBERT BURT FROM SEPTEMBER 14TH AND 15TH 1997.
COURT ORDER REQUESTING CLAIMANT ROBERT BURT'S APPEARANCE. FOR SEPTEMBER 14,
1997
Defense counsel served a response dated November 10, 1999 stating that all of
the requests were overly broad, vague and burdensome and requested information
that was not relevant to the issues in dispute. Claimant's motion ensued. In
opposing the motion, defense counsel now concedes that the requested documents
"have an indicia of relevance", but still maintains that the requests are overly
broad, vague and burdensome.
In the Court's view, claimant's requests are sufficiently specific so as to
enable the defendant to reasonably identify what information is sought and to
conduct a search therefore (see generally Brathwaite v State of New
York, 208 AD2d 231, at 236 and 237).
March 2, 2000
Saratoga
Springs, New York
HON. FRANCIS T. COLLINS
Judge of the Court of
Claims
The Court considered the following papers:
Notice of Motion dated November 15, 1999;
Affidavit of Robert L. Burt sworn to November 22, 1999, with exhibits;
Good faith affidavit of Robert L. Burt sworn to December 24, 1999;
Affirmation in opposition of Glenn C. King dated December 7, 1999.